POLL: Mother takes Davenport to court over parental responsibility law
March 10, 2010 by charlotte.eby
Filed under Growing Pains, Parents Like Me
The Iowa Supreme Court is scrutinizing a Davenport city ordinance that holds parents responsible when their children are arrested or cited for crimes.
The Supreme Court heard arguments in early March in the case of Anne Hensler, a Davenport mother who was cited under the law when her son was accused of drug possession and a curfew violation.
The Iowa Judicial Building in Des Moines, home to the Iowa Supreme Court.
Hensler took the city to court to challenge the ordinance, arguing that she had the right to parent free from undue intrusion by the state. A Scott County judge ruled in her favor, but the city appealed to the Supreme Court.
Under the ordinance, parents of minors who are arrested or cited for crimes are sent warning letters on the first offense. Parents are required to complete parenting classes on the second offense and could face fines of up to $750 on the third.
Davenport City Attorney Tom Warner said the ordinance brought down juvenile crime in the city, before the court ruling last year put the enforcement of it on hold.
He said the law serves as a strong nudge for parents to get help, and he is optimistic that the state’s highest court will uphold it. Warner was unaware of other similar laws in Iowa.
Part of the arguments Tuesday centered around whether the law should be allowed to stay in place when the state already has a Juvenile Court system to handle delinquency cases.
Warner said the city’s parental responsibility ordinance is complementary to the juvenile system, which moves more slowly.
“They may get arrested multiple times and get into even more trouble while this Juvenile Court matter is pending. This is designed to get to them faster,” Warner said of the ordinance.
Parents who take one of six actions outlined in the ordinance to exercise parental control — such as requiring the child to observe a curfew or ensuring the child regularly attends school — can use that as a defense.
Attorney Randall Wilson of the American Civil Liberties Union of Iowa argued that Davenport’s law violates due process rights and intrudes on parental autonomy.
[polldaddy poll=2823502]
